I am not a big American Idol fan, in fact I never watch it when the bad tryouts are over, but that guy from last night with the Paula fan and his own personal song was not funny, he was depressing. I hate to sound trite, but he was a gloomy guy. Making it worse was his “friends and family” telling him how great he was at other things - he has to be better at other things then singing - while he came off somewhere between Stuart from Mad TV and the low talker from Seinfeld. These people seem to just be reinforcing his shyness and gloominess. That guy was just depressing. I really hope he finds something that will let him get out of his shell and live a bit. It is tough to see such a gloomy and introverted guy without a lot of hope and direction.
The final chic - the one that was in two years ago and was disqualified - was a amazing singer, but her dude with the face ink was SCARY!!! Her tats were obvious, but they could be hidden. He could be a real distraction to the PR in her career down the road I think. She is not going out for the lead singer of a female version of Sum41 or Greenday, but American Idol - i.e. MAINSTREAM POP!! If she does not make the final go in American Idol maybe she could do some duet work with Social Distortion / Mike Ness … that would ROCK!!!!